Results by Time of Day: Finding the Hours That Cost You

Lesson 42 · The Journal

Results by Time of Day: Finding the Hours That Cost You

Your setups don’t behave the same at 9:35 and at 1:15. Neither do you. Splitting results by the clock shows where your day actually goes wrong.

Group trades by entry time into a few fixed buckets and compare trade count, win rate and total R.

Look for the bucket with many trades and negative R. That’s usually the leak.

The fix is often a rule, not a skill: “no new trades between X and Y.”

Small-cap momentum trading is lopsided in time. Volume and volatility are usually heaviest near the open, often quieter midday, and pick up again into the close. Your own focus follows its own curve too. Whether that helps or hurts you is something only your journal can answer.

Pick your buckets

Use the same buckets every week so you can compare. All times US Eastern, which is what the US market runs on. If you trade from another time zone, convert before you group, or your “first hour” will be in the wrong place.

Bucket What it usually covers
Premarket Before 9:30. Thinner volume, wider spreads.
9:30–10:00 The open. Fastest moves, most slippage risk.
10:00–11:00 Follow-through or failure of the morning movers.
11:00–14:00 Midday. Often slower and choppier.
14:00–16:00 Afternoon and the close.

If you trade mostly in the first hour, split it more finely, for example into 15-minute blocks.

What to compare

For each bucket: number of trades, win rate, average win and loss in R, and total R. Put them in one table. Then ask three questions:

  • Where is most of my R made? That’s the window to protect.
  • Where do I trade a lot and make little or nothing? That’s where time and fees go.
  • Where are my mistake tags concentrated? Boredom and revenge trades often have a favorite hour.

Turning it into a rule

If one window is clearly negative over a reasonable number of trades, the simplest fix is to stop trading it. Not “trade it better”, just stop. Write it into your plan: “No new positions after 11:00 unless it’s an A setup,” or “Done for the day at 10:30.” Then keep journaling so you can see whether the rule held and whether the rest of your day changed.

Also check the other side. If your results after 14:00 are good but you rarely trade then because you’re tired or already done, that’s worth knowing too.

Watch the sample

A bucket with four trades tells you nothing yet. Wait until each window has enough trades to mean something before you act on it. The sample size lesson covers how many that is.

Putting it together

  1. Group trades by entry time in fixed Eastern-time buckets.
  2. Compare trades, win rate, payoff and total R per bucket.
  3. Look for high trade count with low or negative R.
  4. Turn a clearly negative window into a “don’t trade then” rule.
  5. Don’t act on a bucket with only a handful of trades.

An honest word: a time rule is one of the easiest changes to make and one of the easiest to break. Track whether you actually follow it, not just whether the numbers improved. Educational content only, not financial advice.

Free, by email

Get the journal series in your inbox

All 16 journal lessons in one email, then a short note when a new lesson goes up. Nothing else. Unsubscribe any time.

← Back to all lessons

← Previous: The Five-Minute Daily Recap Next: Results by Share Price: Where Your Losses Cluster →