Lesson 47 · The Journal
Finding a leak is the easy half. The hard half is writing a rule you’ll follow, and then checking fairly whether it did anything.
Write the rule as an if-then you can check with a yes or no.
Test it for a fixed number of trades or weeks before judging it.
Measure two things: how often you followed it, and what happened to the numbers it was meant to fix.
The weekly review ends with one behavioral change for next week. This lesson is about what that change should look like on paper and how to know whether it worked.
Write it so a stranger could check it
A good rule is specific enough that someone reading your journal could tell whether you followed it. Compare:
| Vague | Checkable |
|---|---|
| “Stop chasing.” | If price is more than 2% above my planned entry, I don’t enter. |
| “Be careful midday.” | If it’s after 11:00 Eastern, I only take A setups. |
| “Don’t revenge trade.” | If I take two losses in a row, I stop for 15 minutes before the next trade. |
| “Respect my stops.” | If price hits my stop, I exit. No moving it down. |
(The thresholds are examples. Use numbers that fit your own data and plan.)
Set the test before you start
Decide three things up front:
- How long: a fixed number of trades, say 30, or a fixed number of weeks.
- What you’ll track: add a column, “Rule followed? Y/N”, for every trade the rule applies to.
- What would count as working: the number the rule was meant to fix, like the R lost to chasing, or midday results.
Deciding this in advance stops you from quitting after two bad days or declaring victory after two good ones.
Judge it on two numbers
Adherence first. If you followed the rule 40% of the time, you haven’t tested the rule. You’ve tested ignoring it. Before judging results, get adherence high.
Then the target number. Compare the metric the rule was aimed at, before and after. Keep the sample-size caveat in mind: a small improvement over a small number of trades may be noise.
Keep, adjust or drop
- Keep it if you followed it and the target improved. It becomes part of your trading plan.
- Adjust it if you couldn’t follow it. The rule may be too strict or too vague.
- Drop it if you followed it well and nothing changed. The leak was somewhere else.
Then pick the next most expensive leak and do it again. One rule at a time.
Putting it together
- Write rules as checkable if-then statements.
- Set the test length and the success measure before starting.
- Track “rule followed” on every relevant trade.
- Judge adherence first, results second.
- Keep, adjust or drop, then move to the next leak.
An honest word: a rule that tests well over a few weeks can still stop working later. Keep the adherence column even after a rule becomes part of your plan. Educational content only, not financial advice.
Free, by email
Get the journal series in your inbox
All 16 journal lessons in one email, then a short note when a new lesson goes up. Nothing else. Unsubscribe any time.
← Previous: How Many Trades Before You Trust a Pattern? Next: Journaling Paper Trades and Live Trades Separately →